
Borgo Santandrea
Best for a full-service Amalfi Coast resort experience with multiple restaurants, a private beach club and a dedicated wellness retreat.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Borgo Santandrea is a five-star cliffside Amalfi Coast resort with multiple restaurants, a private beach club and a full wellness retreat; read this if you want a full-service seaside luxury resort. Casa Mariantonia is a small, well-rated boutique inn in Anacapri with a seasonal pool and central island location; read this if you want an intimate base on Capri rather than a large resort.
Updated

Best for a full-service Amalfi Coast resort experience with multiple restaurants, a private beach club and a dedicated wellness retreat.

Best for travelers who want a small, highly rated boutique hotel-style stay in central Anacapri with easy access to Capri sights.
When Borgo Santandrea wins: choose Borgo Santandrea if you want on-site Michelin-star dining, a private white-pebble beach and a full spa, plus more on-property facilities and services for a seaside-resort stay.
When Casa Mariantonia wins: choose Casa Mariantonia if you prefer a small, central Anacapri property with individually decorated rooms, a relaxed island pace and a very high guest score — good for short stays on Capri where you’ll explore the island more than the hotel.
Bottom line: Borgo Santandrea is the pick for a full-service Amalfi luxury resort and seaside dining program; Casa Mariantonia is the pick for boutique, central Anacapri convenience and a compact, highly rated hotel stay.
| Category | Borgo Santandrea | Casa Mariantonia |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Full-service, cliffside Amalfi resort focused on dining, spa and beach club. | Small, boutique inn in Anacapri with individually decorated rooms and a quiet island feel. |
| Location | Perched ~90 m above sea level at Conca dei Marini between Amalfi and Positano; private beach access. | Centrally located in Anacapri (Via G. Orlandi, 180), close to local sights and Marina Grande. |
| Size | About 45 rooms and suites (mix of rooms and suites; multiple suite/plunge-pool options). | 9 individually decorated guestrooms. |
| Ages / audience | Marketed toward adults and couples; hotel publishes a minimum-guest age policy (children accepted from age 8 in many sources). | All-ages property (not adults-only); family/child policies are not restrictive in supplier listing. |
| Pools & beach | Seasonal heated outdoor saltwater pool plus select suites with private heated plunge pools; private white-pebble Marinella Beach Club with sunbeds and a jetty. | Outdoor seasonal pool, hot tub and poolside bar; no private beach listed. |
| Restaurants & bars | Three restaurants (including Michelin-starred Alici), multiple bars including Plumbago and a beach bar. | One restaurant (Zagara), a poolside bar and a cafe/snack options; room service during limited hours. |
| Wellness / fitness | Borgo Santandrea Wellness Retreat with treatments, sauna, emotional shower, Technogym gym and yoga sessions. | Not published. |
| Known for | Cliffside location with private beach club, Michelin-star dining and sea-view wellness. | Intimate, highly rated Anacapri base with private balconies/terraces and Frette sheets. |
| Transport & access | Private boat transfers and complementary Amalfi shuttle; free on-site parking for drivers (Amalfi-side). | Airport shuttle available for a surcharge; scooter/moped rentals and boat tours nearby. |
| Breakfast | Complimentary buffet breakfast included for resident guests. | |
Borgo Santandrea sits on the Amalfi Coast, carved into cliffs about 90 metres above the sea with direct access down to a private beach.
Choose Borgo Santandrea for dramatic sea views and direct beach access from the Amalfi coastline.
Casa Mariantonia is centrally located in Anacapri on Via G. Orlandi, within easy reach of local shops, churches and the Monte Solaro chairlift.
Choose Casa Mariantonia for a central Anacapri base when you plan to spend most of your time sightseeing on Capri.
Borgo Santandrea offers a wide range of rooms and suites, some with private heated plunge pools and broad sea-view terraces.
Borgo Santandrea is the choice if you want suite options and private plunge pools with panoramic Amalfi views.
Casa Mariantonia has 9 individually decorated guestrooms, many with balconies or terraces and Frette Italian sheets.
Choose Casa Mariantonia for a compact, characterful room in central Anacapri rather than a large suite inventory.
Borgo Santandrea runs several on-site dining venues including a Michelin-starred restaurant and a beachfront lunch spot.
Borgo Santandrea suits guests who want a varied, chef-led dining program and formal dining options on site.
Casa Mariantonia’s on-site dining is compact and focused, centered on restaurant Zagara and poolside service.
Casa Mariantonia is best when you plan to eat locally in Anacapri or use the hotel’s single restaurant for convenience.
Borgo Santandrea combines a seasonal heated saltwater pool with direct access to an exclusive private beach club.
If direct beach access and a resort beach club matter, Borgo Santandrea is the clear choice.
Casa Mariantonia offers a seasonal outdoor pool and a hot tub with poolside loungers and a pool bar.
Casa Mariantonia works well for island stays that combine a small hotel pool with easy access to Capri’s beaches and boat options.
Borgo Santandrea provides a full wellness program with a named Wellness Retreat and sea-view fitness facilities.
The resort’s wellness and activity program supports a stay focused on spa, fitness and organized excursions.
Casa Mariantonia supplies typical inn services — concierge, airport shuttle for a surcharge and some activity bookings — but no published on-site spa.
Casa Mariantonia covers essential services for island stays; spa treatments and larger wellness programs are not published.

Borgo Santandrea — three restaurants including Michelin-starred Alici and a beachfront AQVA lunch spot.

Casa Mariantonia — intimate property, 9 individually decorated rooms and a 9.6 guest rating.

Borgo Santandrea — private Marinella Beach Club with jetty and beach service.

Casa Mariantonia — compact inn with included buffet breakfast and a central Anacapri location that saves on island transfers.
Borgo Santandrea: it has a named Wellness Retreat with treatment cabins, sauna, an emotional shower and a sea-view Technogym fitness area. Casa Mariantonia does not publish a spa.
Casa Mariantonia — it’s centrally located in Anacapri near the chairlift and local sights, making island exploration easier; Borgo Santandrea is on the Amalfi Coast and requires a boat/ferry plus transfers to reach Capri.
Yes — both properties publish a complimentary buffet breakfast for resident guests.
No — Borgo Santandrea has a private Marinella Beach Club; Casa Mariantonia does not list a private beach (nearby Marina Grande and island beaches are accessible).
Explore how Borgo Santandrea stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·